Appendix of Exhibits

APPENDIX OF EXHIBITS

EXHIBIT 1   – May 23, 2001 Cuyler BAR Minutes
EXHIBIT 2   – December 2001 Cuyler newsletter
EXHIBIT 3   – Notarized sworn affidavit of Mr. Steven P. Breed, Cuyler Town Supervisor
EXHIBIT 4   – May 16, 2002 Email from Town of Cuyler Assessor Julie Ray
EXHIBIT 5   – May 28, 2002 Cuyler BAR Assessment Determination [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 6   – 2004 Appraisal Report Cover Sheet
EXHIBIT 7   – Data set of properties provided by Assessor Julie Ray
EXHIBIT 7.1  – David W. Perfetti, Esq. Hearing Officer Report [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 8   – Report by SCAR Hearing Officer Libby
EXHIBIT 9   – August 21, 2002 Decision of SCAR Hearing Officer Libby
EXHIBIT 10 – September 4, 2002 Decision by Administrative Judge Judith O’Shea to grant a SCAR re-hearing
EXHIBIT 11 – Town of Cuyler 2002 Land Valuation Schedule
EXHIBIT 12 – October 3, 2002 Decision of SCAR Hearing Officer David Kimpel [Page 2, Page 3]
EXHIBIT 13 – March 2004 Assessment Disclosure Notice
EXHIBIT 14 – Cover letter accompanying the March 2004 Assessment Disclosure Notice
EXHIBIT 15 – March 8, 2004 FOIL (Freedom of Information Law) Request
EXHIBIT 16 – March 11, 2004 Response (cover letter) by Assessor Julie Ray to the March 8, 2004 FOIL Request
EXHIBIT 17 – March 11, 2004 Response (list of properties) by Assessor Julie Ray to the March 8, 2004 FOIL Request
EXHIBIT 18 – March 16, 2004 FOIL (Freedom of Information Law) Request [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 19 – March 23, 2004 Response by Assessor Julie Ray to the March 16, 2004 FOIL Request [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 20 – 2004 Town of Cuyler Land Valuation Schedule
EXHIBIT 21 – May 25, 2004 Cuyler BAR Assessment Determination [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 22 – July 3, 2004 correspondence from Mr. Robert Freeman, Executive Director, State of New York, Department of State, Committee on Open Government [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 23 – July 22, 2004 Decision of SCAR Hearing Officer Thomas Perry [Page 2, Page 3, Page 4]
EXHIBIT 24 – Summary of Valuation Methods [Page 2, Page 3]
EXHIBIT 25 – Model Application Computation Report, Cuyler 2004
EXHIBIT 26 – 2004 Appraisal Report
EXHIBIT 27 – Hughes property specification sheet
EXHIBIT 28 – August 2008 Email to Nedra Griswald, Town of Cuyler Assessor [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 29 – April 24, 2009 Cortland Standard article entitled "Cuyler Rejects Updated Assessment" [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 30 – May 11, 2009 Cortland Standard article entitled "Homer Delays Town Property Revaluation"
EXHIBIT 30.1 – Cuyler Reval 2009
EXHIBIT 30.2 – Cuyler Winners and Losers Flyer
EXHIBIT 31 – 2014 Assessment Notification
EXHIBIT 32 – New York State Publication “How to Estimate the Market Value of Your Home” [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 33 – Summary
EXHIBIT 34 – State of New York Real Property System Comparable Sales Report 
EXHIBIT 35 – 2014 Preliminary Assessment [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 36 – Cover Sheet for 2014 Preliminary Assessment [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 37 – Methodological Summary
EXHIBIT 38 – Expanded Statistical Summary
EXHIBIT 39 – Extended Critique of Assessor’s Methodological Weaknesses
EXHIBIT 40 – 2014 Cuyler BAR Decision
EXHIBIT 41 – Correspondence to Thomas Mattox, NYS Commissioner of Taxation and Finance [Page 2]
EXHIBIT 42 – Correspondence from Thomas Mattox, NYS Commissioner of Taxation and Finance
EXHIBIT 43 – Correspondence to NYS Office of the Comptroller
EXHIBIT 44 – August 7, 2014 Correspondence from NYS Office of the Attorney General’s Public Integrity Bureau
EXHIBIT 45 – July 14, 2014 Correspondence to the Cortland County Clerk [Page 2, Page 3, Page 4]
EXHIBIT 46 – Petition for a Small Claims Assessment Review (SCAR) Hearing [Page 2, Page 3, Page 4]
EXHIBIT 47 – July 30, 2014 SCAR Hearing Transcript 
EXHIBIT 48 – July 30, 2014 SCAR Recording 1
EXHIBIT 49 – July 30, 2014 SCAR Recording 2
EXHIBIT 50 – Documented Need For Roof Replacement
EXHIBIT 51 – Presentation at SCAR hearing
EXHIBIT 52 – Property 210 (Reval 2014) Summary Sheet
EXHIBIT 53 – 2014 SCAR Verdict [Page 2]

ARTICLES OF INTEREST